6 Things Every (Atheist) Blogger Should Know

Last month, my blog turned two and a half years old! That means that today, I’ve been blogging for 136 weeks and this is my 136th post. Over the years, people have asked me for my greatest advice for blog writing, whether that is how to grow a following and get noticed or how to go about writing for an atheist blog when you’re still in the atheist closet. Today, I want to share with you some of my answers to some commonly asked blogging questions.

1. How do I start a blog?

This is a fairly simple question with a straightforward answer. Ask anyone who has ever started a blog, and they will tell you that this is by far the easiest step in blogging. For me, it involved choosing a blog name (The Closet Atheist at the time) and clicking on the big, unmissable Get Started button on WordPress.com. WordPress (almost) literally holds your hand throughout the blog-building process, and there is nothing technical to it. Any WordPress blog can be free, by the way, if you don’t mind a URL ending in .wordpress.com and a few ads on your site. My blog started off as theclosetatheist39.wordpress.com (does anyone remember this?) because theclosetatheist.wordpress.com was (and still is) reserved. But oh, how far we’ve come!

2. How do I start an anonymous blog as a closeted atheist?

The first thing of which I must warn you—which I had to learn the hard way—is not to expect it to stay hidden forever. I think I did a pretty good job of writing anonymously for that year and a half. My name or face were nowhere to be seen on the site, my Twitter, or anywhere related to them. You better believe The Closet Atheist was not only the name of my site, but my second identity. It was my email address and my Twitter handle, and there was not any way that anyone who didn’t know me could have ever found me on Instagram or Facebook through it.

But writing anonymously, continuously, is hard. You can’t write your life story without details of your life slipping in. Even when I was writing anonymously, you would have known that I was raised in the Lutheran Church, that my mom was an organist, my brother-in-law was a pastor, and I went to a Christian college where I played in a marching band. But I think that giving up that many details of my life were worth how much this blog saved my sanity. Even YouTubers make videos anonymously, but I think that puts you at a much higher risk of being found by people you know.

3. How do I keep my blog going?

I’ve seen more blogs than I can count with one post, or a handful of posts, which were then left and never touched again. Thinking of a cool name, a sleek design, and a catchy topic is simple until you realize that if you want your blog to succeed, you are going to have to keep writing. And writing. And writing. And writing. (Repeat, in my case, 136 times so far.)

Not to be harsh, or overly obvious, but you probably shouldn’t start a blog if you don’t have a pretty long list of post ideas. You don’t want a blog with a total of four or five posts, but you want to be able to write for as long as possible, and to do that, you need things to talk about. I think that generating topics is more difficult as a blogger than it would be for a podcast or for YouTube, because on those media, there are endless other videos to reply to, and endless people to invite onto your podcast to interview. But I find that it is nearly impossible to collaborate with others or review videos through blogging, so I stick with reviewing books and articles, and in the past I’ve responded to sermons, speeches, bible studies, and class lectures.

4. How will I ever come up with that much to talk about?

The best way to come up with post ideas is deciding the overall topic of your blog. It absolutely has to be something you are passionate about, and that you could talk about for literal years. And you should be able to put your own spin on it, own it, and write about it from your perspective. If you’re telling your story, it should be easy because no one else can or has told it before. For me, I combined my story of becoming an atheist, living as an atheist at a Christian college and in a Christian family, and coming out to the people in my life. On quiet weeks, I interspersed my life experiences with the aforementioned reviews and responses. Nowadays, with my atheist story being quiet and peaceful, I’ve started branching out from the topic of atheism and religion—to posts like this!

5. How do I grow my following?

Here’s my practical, tried-and-true advice: Engage. This is true for every content creator: YouTubers, Instagrammers, and traditional bloggers alike. Comment on, follow, and like other people’s blogs and blog posts. Follow them on social media and interact with them there. The audience will follow if you have built relationships with people. This also means that you can’t make it all about you. If you comment on anyone’s blog saying only “Nice post! Check out my blog at doucheymcdouche.wordpress.com,” they will probably delete it immediately, if it doesn’t get sent automatically to spam. If the post you are commenting on is something you’ve also written about, you should still summarize your thoughts in your comments before linking to your specific post and explaining why. But I find that it is always good enough to not self-advertise at all. Just be logged in, where your blog link will be in your username automatically.

But on a more authentic, less marketing-centered level, it is really all about what you are actually writing. I am a firm believer, when it comes to personal blogging (as opposed to marketing blogs or other paid content), in this unpopular opinion.

The writer comes first. The readers come second.

This probably goes against any blogging advice you have ever read. But for he or she who blogs unpaid, just to tell their story, it is vital. If you write what you want to write, you will have more fun, you will write better, and your readers will know that you love what you’re doing. This is how you keep them around, and this is how you keep your blog going before you decide that it’s “just too hard,” it’s “not fun anymore,” and “no one’s reading it anyway and I can’t figure out what they want!” Just keep going. At the very least, you will be enjoying it. Even among my own readership, I can tell you right now that no matter what, this blog’s biggest fan is me!

6. What’s your biggest advice for anyone who wants to get into blogging?


I cannot stress this enough. At all. Is it absolutely crucial.

I follow a number of blogs, and I can’t tell you how much it drives me crazy when they do not keep a posting schedule, especially when they claim to! If you tell your audience you will upload every Tuesday at 11 a.m., you have to upload every Tuesday at 11 a.m. This is part of building trust. My readers knew that this post would be up today at 8 a.m., and I know that my views are always highest on Sunday mornings. I have never kept my readers wondering for longer than 12 hours where my last post was or when I would write next. There are many Saturdays when I don’t have time to write, and there are no Sundays (anymore) when I am up by 8 a.m. One of the greatest things about WordPress is the ability to write a post any time you want and schedule it to go up when you want it to.

When I was in a graphic design class in college, one of my projects was to make an instructional infographic. I chose a how-to on personal blogging. So if you want a more concise and design-centric list of blogging tips from me, you can look at this poster called “5 Traits of a Successful Personal Blog”.

Do you think I missed anything or do you have any other blogging questions? Let me know!

24 thoughts on “6 Things Every (Atheist) Blogger Should Know

  • Your seriously successful blog has me reeling in between envy and depression. But I shouldn’t be: I am in this so atheism would be defended. I do it my way, you do it your way. Even if I lose I win. Your advise on “write about what you want” boosted me. I write long, with endless rereading and correcting. Probably only a handful people ever finished a post of mine, but I can’t do quick or superficial I need to be exhaustive nuanced and right about all of it. All I can say is: I am still here. Congrats on your push for humanity. Tom Cruise, unlike his minions think, isn’t saving humanity single handed, but you might!

    Liked by 1 person

  • One thing I recommend, let life be your muse when it comes to blogging. Seriously. When you can just step back and look at life from a slightly different angle it’s enormously amusing.

    Liked by 2 people

  • It also helps if you can find humor in what you do, or think, and responding to other people’s blogs (with more than, whoa, funny post) helps. It makes them curious as to what you might be up to.

    And there is no crime in writing ahead. If you think of it as a newspaper column, you know that columnists have a backlog of ’emergency’ columns, both written out and idea’d out to work from on the dry days. It doesn’t hurt to work up a few on days when you’re feeling wordy, for future reference.

    Liked by 2 people

  • I think the not sticking to a schedule nor linking my posts to a social media account is why my viewership is so low compared to many others. However you gotta do what works for you and this works for me. Been blogging for 5 years and I haven’t run out of ideas yet!

    Liked by 2 people

  • Overall, I thought that was a pretty good summary of what it takes to blog.

    I disagree with this one: “Not to be harsh, or overly obvious, but you probably shouldn’t start a blog if you don’t have a pretty long list of post ideas.”

    I disagree, because a short list of ideas is as good as a long list of ideas. If you are working from a list of ideas, you will run out.

    What you really need, is a source from which you can generate new ideas. I your case, that was your atheism and deconversion. And you have been successful in using that source to replenish your list of idea.

    And this seems important: “The writer comes first. The readers come second.” If you are writing for other people, it can become very lonesome if you doubt that there are many readers. So write for yourself — not to see yourself in print, but because of what you will learn by finding ways to clearly express your ideas.

    Liked by 3 people

  • I tend to write about religious/Christian/atheistic/political issues … and do so as the mood (or news) strikes me. However, I do try to post something on a somewhat regular basis.

    To me, interaction is probably the most important part of blogging. If you don’t respond to your visitor’s comments, they won’t be back. And always include a Category!

    Liked by 3 people

  • I used to have a blog, but I didn’t adhere to number 4 and 6 on your list; Decide on an overall topic and stick to a schedule. One day I’d write a short fiction story. The next week a poem. Then an opinion on an off the wall topic. I was too scattered.
    I like knowing that Sunday’s, for me, include reading The Curious Atheist.

    Liked by 1 person

  • Good advice. I found that posting atheist related topics mixed in with my Litereary Journey blog was distracting. So, I created a second site and posted every day there for a while. Now I find it hard to post 2x a week on both. However, you made me think about it. I need to finish my posts and get them up.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s